cakecafé & bakery · Geneva
Menu Cakes Holiday Orders Team Orders About Visit Order Pickup

142 Castle Street, Geneva NY
Thursday to Sunday · (315) 828-5005
@eatatcake on Instagram

Café and bakery in Geneva, NY

Bagels, coffee, and a slice of cake.

142 Castle Street. Stop in, or order ahead for pickup.

142 Castle Street, GenevaThursday & Friday 7am to 2pmSaturday 8am to 2pmSunday 10am to 2pm(315) 828-5005142 Castle Street, GenevaThursday & Friday 7am to 2pmSaturday 8am to 2pmSunday 10am to 2pm(315) 828-5005142 Castle Street, GenevaThursday & Friday 7am to 2pmSaturday 8am to 2pmSunday 10am to 2pm(315) 828-5005142 Castle Street, GenevaThursday & Friday 7am to 2pmSaturday 8am to 2pmSunday 10am to 2pm(315) 828-5005

What sounds good?

Need a cake for a big day?

Tell us the date and how many people. We’ll text you a price.

Strawberry cream cake from above Ferrero Rocher cake Cookies and cream cake, cut open, in the front window

What Geneva says.

★★★★★
★★★★★

“First time here + definitely not my last. The gals are so sweet and helpful. Homemade everything!! Got my first ever pumpkin spice latte - officially get the hype. Don't skip the cold foam.”

Dara E., Google review
★★★★★

“I have told people all over the fingerlakes how amazing these bagels are!!!”

Sarah B., Google review
★★★★★

“The bagels & pastries are out of this world! The space is cute and the service is friendly. I had a layered chocolate cake that was to die for.”

Ashley C., Google review
★★★★★

“I've been here twice now, and I can't rave enough. The ladies that run the place are local. Their Iced latte is a highlight for me (they have a sweet coconut cold foam). Bagels are delicious.”

K. L., Google review
★★★★★

“Absolute gem - the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the treats are out of this world. I will be back for more croissants.”

Katie F., Google review
★★★★★

“The best bagel sandwiches in the finger lakes!”

Matthew K., Google review
★★★★★

“Everything is amazing, and especially this key lime pie! It's so great to have a wonderful bakery so close to home.”

Geoffrey H., Google review
★★★★★

“This bakery is a lovely addition to Geneva, beautifully decorated down to the lovely plates. The two ladies working were both very thoughtful and helpful.”

Mandy R., Google review
★★★★★

“The breakfast bagel sandwich was AMAZING. I had egg and cheese on an everything bagel. It was the perfect crunch and not too thick.”

Jennifer B., Google review
★★★★★

“Lovely people and delicious food. Stopped to pick up a slice of cake for an early birthday celebration for my husband. He very much enjoyed the Ferrero Rocher cake and the Triple Chocolate…”

Rachael V., Google review
★★★★★

“This bakery is so great! We had breakfast and had to come back for more the next day. The pink walls are my personal favorite touch.”

K. K., Google review
★★★★★

“This place is absolutely amazing!! Their breakfast sandwiches, cake slices, coffee, and glazed croissants are so good!!”

Meg H., Google review
★★★★★

“The triple chocolate mousse cake was so good!! Love the atmosphere and the owners are super nice.”

A. G., Google review
★★★★★

“My family couldn't get enough of the sweet treats at Cake! We had to take extra sweets home because they looked so delicious!”

Peter M., Google review
★★★★★

“The cake at cake was every bit as delicious as we dreamed it would be from the photos we saw online!”

Jess F., Google review
★★★★★

“Cake is an awesome new bakery! Great to have a choice for delicious sweets and fresh bagels downtown.”

Dave L., Google review
★★★★★

“A delicious experience, a buttery Croissant in a beautifully designed spot!”

Andrea M., Google review
★★★★★

“Everything was delicious, especially the key lime pie.”

Terri H., Google review
★★★★★

“Is it approval enough that I've stopped by for cookies twice in a month? They're really good.”

David S., Google review
★★★★★

“My first time finally getting to drop by Cake was a HUGE success!”

Taylor H., Google review
★★★★★

“Best cake, coffee, and service in New York”

Collin A., Google review
★★★★★

“Outstanding addition to Geneva!”

Zachary S., Google review

Bringing food for a group?

Four pecan pies topped with whipped cream

Holiday orders

Pies and cakes, by pre-order.

See Holiday Orders
A tray of glazed croissants

Office and group orders

Tell us how many people and when.

Ask About a Group Order
A basket of blueberry bagels

HWS care packages

Treats delivered to your student’s dorm.

See Care Packages
cake storefront at 142 Castle Street

Come see us on Castle Street.

142 Castle Street
Geneva, NY 14456

  • Thursday and Friday: 7am to 2pm
  • Saturday: 8am to 2pm
  • Sunday: 10am to 2pm
  • Monday to Wednesday: closed

Call us: (315) 828-5005

Get new menu items
and holiday orders first.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy